Progress towards the innovation potential of the European union member states using grey relational analysis and multidimensional scaling methods




Innovation potential; innovation policy; sustainable economic development; Grey Relational Analysis and multidimensional scaling methods


The article presents the results of a study aimed at assessing the level of innovation potential of European Union member states. The research was based on 8 diagnostic variables characterizing the two most important dimensions of innovation, namely human resources and R&D expenditures. As a result of the research, the levels of innovation potential of European Union countries between 2010-2020 were specified. The GRA approach and multidimensional scaling were used for the study. Based on the results, the European Union countries were divided into 4 classes. The findings showed large differences in this potential across countries, which was graphically illustrated by using the multidimensional scaling method. In addition, using two non-parametric tests, (Spearman Rank Correlation Coefficient and Kendall Correlation Coefficient), relationships between the innovation potential of member states and selected economic and innovation parameters of their economies were determined. The results of the study indicate that in the old EU-14 countries, this level was at a significantly higher level than in the new EU-13 countries. The EU-27 innovation potential leaders were found to be Finland, Sweden, Luxembourg, Denmark, and Germany. The worst performers, on the other hand, are Malta and Romania. Also, geographically, there were noticeable differences between the countries studied. The results presented should be used to develop strategies and implement policies for sustainable innovative development in the European Union. To the best of the authors' knowledge, this study is a new contribution to assessing the level of innovation potential of European Union member countries and determining the relationship of this potential with selected parameters of the economy of these countries.


Download data is not yet available.


Abubakar, A., Kassim, S.H.J., & Yusoff, M.B. (2015). Financial development, human capital accumulation and economic growth: empirical evidence from the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS). Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 172, 96–103.

Acs, Z., & Audretsch, D.B. (1987). Innovation, Market Structure, and Firm Size, Review of Economic and Statistics, 69, 4.

Aghion, P., & Howitt, P. (1997). Endogenous growth theory. MIT Press.

Andrew, A.M. (2011). Why the World is Grey, Grey Systems-Theory and Application; Emerald Group Publishing Limited: Bingley, UK, 1, 112–116.

Ang, J.B., & Madsen, J.B. (2011). Can second-generation endogenous growth models explain the productivity trends and knowledge production in the Asian miracle economies? Review of Economics and Statistics, 93, 1360–1373.

Annique Un, V., & Rodríguez, A. (2018). Local and Global Knowledge Complementarity: R&D Collaborations and Innovation of Foreign and Domestic Firm. Journal of International Management, 24, 137-152.

Anselmo Alvarez, P., Ishizaka, A., & Martínez, L. (2021). Multiple-criteria decision-making sorting methods: A survey. Expert Systems with Applications, 183, 115368.

Archibugi, D., & Filippetti, A. (2011). Is the economic crisis impairing convergence in innovation performance across. Journal of Common Market Studies, 49(6), 1153–1182.

Asteriou, D., & Agiomirgianakis, G.M. (2001). Human Capital and Economic Growth: Time Series Evidence from Greece. J. Policy Modeling, 23, 481–489.

Atkinson, R.D., & Ezell, S.J. (2014). Innovation Economics: The Race for Global Advantage, Yale University Press, New Haven.

Badi, I., & Pamucar, D. (2020). Supplier selection for steelmaking company by using combined grey-marcos methods. Decision Making: Applications in Management and Engineering, 3, 37-47.

Badinger, G., & Tondl, H. (2003). Trade, Human Capital and Innovation: The Engines of European Regional Growth in the 1990s. In European Regional Growth; Fingleton, B., Ed.; Springer: Berlin/Heidelberg, Germany.

Barra, C., & Zotti, R. (2016). The contribution of university, private and public sector resources to Italian regional innovation system (in)efficiency. Journal of Technology Transfer, 43 (2), 432-457.

Bassanini, A., Scarpetta, S., & Hemmings, P. (2001). Economic Growth: The Role of Policies and Institutions: Panel Data. Evidence from OECD Countries, OECD Economics Department Working Papers, No. 283, OECD Publishing, Paris.

Becker, G. (1962). Investment in Human Capital: A Theoretical Analysis. Journal of Political Economy, 70, 9-49.

Becker, G.S. (1994). Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis, with Special Reference to Education; The University of Chicago Press: Chicago, IL, USA.

Behzadian, M., Khanmohammadi Otaghsara, S., Yazdani, M., & Ignatius, J. (2012). A state-of the-art survey of TOPSIS applications. Expert Syst. Appl. 39, 13051–13069.

Belenkova, O., Vanchukhina, L., & Leybert, T. (2008). Human capital as socio-economic phenomenon of the innovation society: pre-requisites of formation, essence and structure. SHS Web of Conferences, 55, 01003.

Bianchi, T. (2001). With and without co-operation: Two alternative strategies in the food-processing industry in the Italian South. Entrepreneurship & Regional Development, 13, 117–145.

Billon, M., Marco, R., & Lera-Lopez, F. (2017). Innovation and ICT use in the EU: An analysis of regional drivers. Empirical Economics, 53(3), 1083-1108.

Bouis, R., Duval, R., & Murtin, F. (2011). The Policy and Institutional Drivers of Economic Growth Across OECD and Non-OECD Economies: New Evidence from Growth Regressions", OECD Economics Department Working Papers, No. 843, OECD Publishing, Paris.

Brans, J.P., Mareschal, B., & Vincke, P. (1984). PROMETHEE: A new family of outranking methods in multicriteria analysis. In Operational Research ‘84 IFORS 84, 6–10 August 1984, Washington, DC, USA.

Brauers, W.K.M., & Zavadskas, E.K. (2006). The MOORA method and its application to privatization in a transition economy. Control and Cybernetics, 35, 443–468.

Buesa, M., Heijsa, J., & Baumert, T. (2010). The determinants of regional innovation in Europe: A combined factorial and regression knowledge production function approach. Research Policy, 39, 722-735.

Burcu, O., & Ayse, A. (2014). The relationship between research & development expenditures and economic growth: Panel data analysis. Maliye Dergis, 166, 39-55.

Chataway, J., Hanlin, R., & Kaplinsky, R. (2014). Inclusive innovation: an architecture for policy development. Innovation and Development, 4, 33-54.

Cieślik, A., & Wciślik D. (2020). Convergence among the CEE-8 economies and their catch-up towards the EU-15. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 55, 39-48.

Constantin, M., Dinu, M., Pătărlăgeanu, S., & Chelariu, C. (2021). Sustainable Development Disparities in the EU-27 Based on R&D and Innovation Factors. The Amfiteatru Economic Journal, 23, 948-948.

Corradini, M., Costantini, V., Mancinelli, S., & Mazzanti, M. (2014). Unveiling the dynamic relation between R&D and emission abatement: National and sectoral innovation perspectives from the EU. Ecological Economics, 102, 48-59.

Cuaresma, J.C., Doppelhofer, G., & Feldkircher, M. (2014). The determinants of economic growth in European regions. Regional Studies, 48, 44–67.

Cumming, G.S., & von Cramon-Taubadel, S. (2018). Linking economic growth pathways and environmental sustainability by under-standing development as alternate social–ecological regimes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 115, 9533–9538.

Dakhi, M., & de Clercq, D. (2007). Human capital, social capital, and innovation: A multi-country study. Entrepreneurship and Regional Development, 16, 107–128.

De Rassenfosse, G., & van Pottelsberghe de la Potterie, B. (2012). On the price elasticity of demand for patents Oxford. Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 74 (1), 58-77.

Deng, J. (1989). Introduction to Grey System Theory. The Journal of grey system, 1, 1-24.

Diebolt, C., & Hippe, R. (2022). Human Capital and Regional Development in Europe. A Long-Run Comparative View. Springer Cham.

di Liberto, A. (2008). Education and Italian regional development. Economics of Education Review, 27, 94–107.

Dworak, E., Grzelak, M.M., & Roszko-Wójtowicz, E. (2022). Comparison of National Innovation Systems in the European Union Countries. Risks, 10, 6-15.

Engelbrecht, H.J. (2002). Human capital and international knowledge spillovers in TFP growth of a sample of developing countries: An exploration of alternative approaches. Applied Economics, 37, 831–841.

European Commission (2010). Communication from the Commission Europe 2020. A strategy for smart, sustainable and inclusive growth. Accessed 03 December 2022.

European innovation scoreboard. Accessed 03 December 2022.

Eurostat. Database (2010-2020). Accessed 03 December 2022.

Feldman, M. (2000). Location and Innovation: The New Economic Geography of Innovation, Spillovers, and Agglomeration, in: G. Clark, M. Feldman and M. Gertler (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Economic Geography. New York. NY: Oxford University Press.

Fredman, N. (2014). Understanding motivation for study: Human capital or human capability? International Journal of Training Research, 12, 93-105.

Fritsch, M., & Franke, G. (2004). Innovation, regional knowledge spillovers and R&D cooperation. Research Policy, 33, 245-255.

Gerus-Gościewska, M., & Gościewski, D. (2022). Grey Relational Analysis (GRA) as an Effective Method of Research into Social Preferences in Urban Space Planning. Land, 11, 10-22.

Global Innovation Index. Accessed 03 December 2022.

Gocer, I. (2013). Effects of R&D expenditures on high technology exports, balance of foreign trade and economic growth. Maliye Dergisi, 165, 215-240.

Grigoriou, K., & Rothaermel, F. T. (2014). Structural microfoundations of innovation: The role of relational stars. Journal of Management, 40, 586–615.

Griliches, Z. (1990). Patent Statistics as Economic Indicators: A Survey. Journal of Economic Literature, 28, 287-343.

Grossman, G.M., & Helpman, E. (1990). Trade, innovation, and growth. American Economic Review, 80, 86–91.

Grossman, G.M., & Helpman, E. (1994). Endogenous innovation in the theory of growth. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 8(1), 23–44.

Grzelak, M., Laskowska, I., & Roszko‑Wójtowicz, E. (2018). The Importance of Research and Development Expenditure for the Competitiveness of Manufacturing Enterprises in Poland. The Application of Panel Models. Econometrics/Ekonometria, 22, 9-22.

Guellec, D., & Ralle, P. (1991). Product innovation and endogenous growth. Document de Travail INSEE.

Guellec, D., & van Pottelsberghe de la Potterie, B. (2000). The Impact of Public R&D Expenditure on Business R&D", OECD Science, Technology and Industry Working Papers, No. 2000/04, OECD Publishing, Paris.

Guloglu, B., & Baris Tekin, R. (2012). A panel causality analysis of the relationship among research and development, innovation, and economic growth in high-income OECD countries. Eurasian Economic Review, 2(1), 32-47.

Healy, S., & Côté, S. (2001). The Well-Being of Nations: The Role of Human and Social Capital. Education and Skills; OECD: Paris, France.

Helfat, C.E., & Martin, J.A. (2014). Dynamic managerial capabilities: Review and assessment of managerial impact on strategic change. Journal of Management, 40, 1–32.

Jagódka, M., & Snarska, M. (2021). The State of Human Capital and Innovativeness of Polish Voivodships in 2004–2018. Sustainability, 13, 126-139.

Kaneva M., & Untura G. (2018). The impact of R&D and knowledge spillovers on the economic growth of Russian region. Growth and Change, 50, 301–334.

Keršulienė, V., & Turskis. Z. (2011). Integrated fuzzy multiple criteria decision making model for architect selection. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 17, 645–66.

Keshavarz, G.M. Zavadskas, E.K., Olfat, L., & Turskis, Z. (2015). Multi-criteria inventory classification using a new method of evaluation based on distance from average solution (EDAS). Informatica, 26, 435–451.

Keshavarz, G.M., Zavadskas, E., Turskis, Z., & Antucheviciene, J. (2016). A new combinative distance-based assessment (CODAS) method for multi-criteria decision-making. Economic Computation and Economic Cybernetics Studies and Research, 50, 25–44.

Kim, J., & Kim, W. (2022). The intensity and diversity of R&D partner types and product development: Do product innovation types and industry sectors matter? Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 184, 121958.

Kaur, M., & Singh, L. (2016). R&D Expenditure and Economic Growth: An Empirical Analysis. International Journal of Technology Management & Sustainable Development, 15, 195-213.

Kordoš, M. (2016). Effects of the EU competition policy and strategy symbiosis. In: International Conference on European Integration. Ostrava: VŠB-TU Ostrava, Faculty of Economics, 472-479.

Kraftowa, I., & Kraft J. (2018). The Relationship between Pro-Innovation Factors and the Performance of the European Union Member States and their Regions. Inzinerine Ekonomika-Engineering Economics, 29(4), 424–433.

Kucharčíková, A. (2011). The Human Capital as the Production Factor. Scientific Papers of University of Pardubice, Faculty of Economics and Administration, 1, 125-133.

Lipnik, A., & Bucar, M. (2017). Measuring the effectiveness of innovation policy. Teorija in Praksa 54 (3-4), 437–447.

Lisbon strategy (2000). Accessed 03 December 2022.

Liu, K. (2014). Human capital, social collaboration, and patent renewal within U.S. pharmaceutical firms. Journal of Management, 40, 616–636.

Ma, L. Zhai, X., Zhong, W., & Zhang, Z. (2019). Deploying human capital for innovation: A study of multi-country manufacturing firms. International Journal of Production Economics, 208, 241-253.

Melnikas, B. (2010). Sustainable development and creation of the knowledge economy: The new theoretical approach, Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 16(3), 516-540.

Mincer, J. (1984). Human capital and economic growth. Economics of Education Review, 3, 195–205.

Miron, E., Erez, M., & Naveh, E. (2004). Do personal characteristics and cultural values that promote innovation, quality, and efficiency compete or complement each other? Journal of Organizational Behavior, 25, 175–199.

Mulas-Granados, C., & Sanz, I. (2008). The dispersion of technology and income in Europe: Evolution and mutual relationship across regions. Research Policy, 37(5), 836–848.

New Sources of Growth: Knowledge-Based Capital (2013). Key Analyses and Policy Conclusion. Accessed 03 December 2022.

Ober, J. (2022). Open Innovation in the ICT Industry: Substantiation from Poland. Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity, 8(3), 158.

Ober, J., & Kochmańska, A. (2022). Remote Learning in Higher Education: Evidence from Poland. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(21), 14479.

Opricovic, S., & Tzeng, G.H. (2004). Compromise solution by MCDM methods: A comparative analysis of VIKOR and TOPSIS. European Journal of Operational Research, 156, 445–455.

Pamucar, D., & Cirovic, G. (2015). The selection of transport and handling resources in logistics centers using Multi-Attributive Border Approximation area Comparison (MABAC). Expert Systems with Applications, 42, 3016–302.

Pamucar, D., Vasin, L., & Lukovac, L. (2014). Selection of railway level crossings for investing in security equipment using hybrid DEMATEL-MARICА model. In: XVI international scientific-expert conference on railway, Railcon 2014, 89–92.

Pegkas, P., Staikouras, C., & Tsamadias, C. (2019). Does research and development expenditure impact innovation? Evidence from the European Union countries. Journal of Policy Modeling, 41, 1005-1025.

Phale, K., Li, F., Mensah, I., Omari-Sasu, A., & Musah, M. (2021). Knowledge-Based Economy Capacity Building for Developing Countries: A Panel Analysis in Southern African Development Community. Sustainability, 13(5), 2890.

Pranolo, A., & Widyastuti, SM. (2014). Simple additive weighting method on intelligent agent for urban forest health monitoring. Proceeding - 2014 Int. Conf. Comput. Control Informatics Its Appl “New Challenges Oppor Big Data”, IC3INA 2014. 132-135.

Qamruzzaman, M.D., Wei, J., Sharmin, J., & Zhu, Y. (2021). Financial innovation, human capital development, and economic growth of selected South Asian countries: An application of ARDL approach. International Journal of Finance & Economics, 26, 4032-4053.

Regulation EU no 1291/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 December 2013 establishing Horizon 2020 - the Framework Programme for Research and Innovation (2014-2020) and repealing Decision No 1982/2006/EC.

Roy, B. (1698). Classement et choix en presence de point de vue multiples: Le methode ELECTRE. La Revued’Informatique et de Recherche Opérationnelle (RIRO), 8, 57–75.

Saaty, T.L. (1980). The Analytical Hierarchy Process; McGraw-Hill: New York, NY, USA.

Salleh, N., Bujang, I., Andin, C., & Mazlan, M. (2022). The Impact of Human Capital Index on Economic Growth in Malaysia. Proceedings, 82(1), 71.

Samara, E., Georgiadis, P., & Bakouros, I. (2012). The Impact of Innovation Policies on the Performance of National Innovation Systems: A System Dynamics Analysis. Technovation, 32, 624–638.

Savrul, M., & Incekara. A. (2015). The Effect of R&D Intensity on Innovation Performance: A Country Level Evaluation. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 210, 388-396.

Scherer, F. M. (1965). Corporate Inventive Output, Profits, and Growth, Journal of Political Economy, 73, 3.

Schmookler, J. (1966). Invention and Economic Growth. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Schultz, T.W. (1961). Investment in Human Capital. American Economic Review, 51, 1-17.

Siwiec, D., Dwornicka, R., & Pacana, A. (2022). Improving the Quality of Products from Cast Alloy with the use of Grey Relational Analysis (GRA). Materials Research Proceedings, 24, 204 – 211.

Soete, L., Verspagen, B., & Ziesemer, T. (2022). Economic impact of public R&D: an international perspective. Industrial and Corporate Change, 31, 1–18.

Sterlacchini, A. (2008). R&D, higher education and regional growth: Uneven linkages among European regions. Res. Policy, 37, 1096–1107.

Stevic, Z., Pamucar, D., Puška, A., & Chaterjee, P. (2020). Sustainable supplier selection in healthcare industries using a new MCDM method: Measurement of Alternatives and Ranking according to COmpromise Solution (MARCOS). Computers & Industrial Engineering, 2020, 140, 10623.

Szopik-Depczyńska, K., Kędzierska-Szczepaniak, A., Szczepaniak, K., Cheba, K. Gajda, W., & Ioppolo, G. (2018). Innovation in sustainable development: an investigation of the EU context using 2030 agenda indicators. Land Use Policy, 79, 251-262.

Tenreiro Machado, J., Duarte, F., & Monteiro Duarte, G. (2011). Analysis of stock market indices through multidimensional scaling. Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation, 16, 4610-4618.

Terzić, L. (2017). The role of innovation in fostering competitiveness and economic growth: Evidence from developing economies. Comparative Economic Research, 20(4), 65-81.

Tutak, M., Brodny, J., & Bindzar, P. (2021). Assessing the Level of Energy and Climate Sustainability in the European Union Countries in the Context of the European Green Deal Strategy and Agenda 2030. Energies, 14(6), 17-29.

Ulewicz, R., Siwiec, D., Pacana, A., Tutak, M., & Brodny, J. (2021). Multi-criteria method for the selection of renewable energy sources in the polish industrial sector. Energies, 14(9), 23-36.

Ulku, H. (2004). R&D, Innovation, and Economic Growth: An Empirical Analysis, IMF Working Paper, WP, 04, 185.

Veugelers, R. (2017). Missing convergence in innovation capacity in the EU: Facts and policy implications. European Economy - Discussion Paper 066, European Commission.

Verba, M. (2022). Growth and innovation in the presence of knowledge and R&D accumulation dynamics. Economics of Innovation and New Technology, 31, 485-510.

Veselá, D., & Klimová, K. (2014). Knowledge-based Economy vs. Creative Economy. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 141, 413-417.

Walburn, D. (2010). Europe 2020. Local Economy, 25(8), 699-702.

Wei, G-W. (2010). GRA method for multiple attribute decision making with incomplete weight information in intuitionistic fuzzy setting. Knowledge-Based Systems, 23, 243-247.

Yazdani, M., Zarate, P., Kazimieras Zavadskas, E., & Turskis, Z. (2019). A combined compromise solution (CoCoSo) method for multi-criteria decision-making problems. Management Decision, 57, 2501-2519.

Zavadskas, E., Antucheviciene, J., Šaparauskas, J., & Turskis, Z. (2013). MCDM methods WASPAS and MULTIMOORA: Verification of robustness of methods when assessing alternative solutions. Economic computation and economic cybernetics studies and research, 47, 5–20.

Zhu, Y., Tian, D., & Yan, F. (2020). Effectiveness of Entropy Weight Method in Decision. Mathematical Problems in Engineering, 2020, 3564835.



How to Cite

Tutak, M., & Brodny, J. (2023). Progress towards the innovation potential of the European union member states using grey relational analysis and multidimensional scaling methods. Decision Making: Applications in Management and Engineering, 6(1), 186–218.